How OwlCrate Drove 11X ROI With an Exclusive Fall-Themed Challenge
Heading into fall, OwlCrate wanted to harness the excitement of the season and inspire ambassadors to create cozy, bookish content. Learn how they drove 11X ROI by partnering with LoudCrowd.
71.6%
Increase in Social Posts
7%
Increase in Engagement
603%
Higher Member Spend
11X
ROI
"Running a challenge through LoudCrowd is incredibly quick and easy to set up, while also delivering results. OwlCrate's customer base is passionate, and having the OwlCrate Collective is an excellent way to engage with our customers through UGC."
ABOUT OWLCRATE
OwlCrate is a subscription service for book lovers, delivering beautifully curated boxes filled with special-edition novels and literary goodies. With a passionate and highly engaged community of readers, OwlCrate has built a brand that thrives on creativity, connection, and the joy of sharing stories. Their ambassador program, OwlCrate Collective, welcomes anyone who wants to join, making it easy for customers to engage with the brand, earn rewards, and share their love of books.
THE CHALLENGE
Heading into fall, OwlCrate wanted to harness the excitement of the season and inspire ambassadors to create cozy, bookish content. They designed an exclusive week-long challenge for their community of ambassadors, encouraging members to share autumn-inspired book stacks. Ambassadors could use books they already owned, styled with seasonal décor, or purchase new books for their fall book stacks using their earned rewards within the ambassador program.
The goal of running this exclusive challenge was to:
- Generate a surge of seasonal content that could be repurposed across Owlcrate’s social and marketing campaigns
- Deepen engagement within the program by offering a fun, low-barrier way to participate
To maximize awareness, OwlCrate announced the challenge via email and made announcements in their LoudCrowd Creator Hub, a place where creators can track their content, rewards earned, and more. Several reminders were sent throughout the week to keep the momentum high, as well. To qualify, ambassadors were asked to include #OCFallVibes in their captions, ensuring OwlCrate could easily track participation and engagement within the LoudCrowd platform.
THE RESULT
The challenge sparked an enthusiastic response from OwlCrate’s community:
- +71.6% increase in Instagram Feed and Reel posts during the week of the challenge
- 7.12% engagement rate on challenge posts, showing how well the content resonated
- +603% increase in member spend the week before the challenge kicked off, as ambassadors stocked up on new books ahead of time
- +266% increase in member spend following the challenge, suggesting participants eagerly redeemed and used the reward they earned for participating
- 11X ROI from the campaign
WHY IT WORKED
OwlCrate knows its audience deeply. By tapping into the seasonal excitement of fall and leaning into the natural passions of their book-loving community, they created a challenge that felt authentic and fun.
A few key factors made this activation successful:
- Seasonal Relevance: The “cozy fall” theme aligned perfectly with the community’s interests.
- Low Barrier to Entry: Participants didn’t need to make new purchases to join, but many chose to, increasing member spend.
- Reward Timing: Running the challenge right after the ambassador program’s monthly rewards were sent out to creators drove even higher redemption and participation.
- Compelling Incentives: Every participant earned points to shop on-site, while one lucky winner was selected at random to receive a bonus lump sum of points, keeping the challenge both inclusive and exciting.
- Strong Communication: Multiple reminders and inspiring example posts kept the challenge top-of-mind.
CONCLUSION
OwlCrate’s challenge proves that with the right theme and thoughtful execution, even a small reward can generate an outsize impact. By fueling creativity, rewarding participation, and aligning with seasonal excitement, they turned a simple activation into an 11X ROI success story.
71.6%
Increase in Social Posts
7%
Increase in Engagement
603%
Higher Member Spend
11X
ROI
Check out other case studies
How Living Proof Achieved 5.4x ROI and a CPA 85% Lower than Industry Average with Their Creator-Affiliate Program
Discover how science-backed haircare brand Living Proof scaled a high-performing creator-affiliate program in just six months.